| Dustin | Abeita | Dine College |
| Timmy | Callahan | SUNY ESF |
| Patrick | Gonzalez | Southern Virginia University |
| Ronald | Hicks | Dine College |
| Justin | Richardson | SUNY Canton |
| Taylor | Yerrick | SUNY ESF |
| Stephen | Slonosky | SUNY ESF |
2012 USCAA Men's Cross Country Second Team All-Americans
| Ryan | McAnany | University of Dallas |
| Herbert | Beyale, III | Dine College |
| Cory | Roth | Paul Smith's College |
| Brian | Busby | SUNY ESF |
| Jon | Cleveland | SUNY ESF |
| Javier | Secaira | University of Dallas |
| Jeremy | Driscoll | SUNY ESF |