2012 USCAA Men's Soccer All-Americans
| Rodrigo | Manzanares | WVU Tech |
| Kennard | Brown | Maine-Fort Kent |
| Joseph | Jackson | WVU Tech |
| Jarryd | Phillips | Maine-Fort Kent |
| Tyler | Troup | Maine-Machias |
| Adam | Freeman | Southern Virginia University |
| Vincent | Mitchell | Concordia College Alabama |
| Kyle | Siegel | SUNY ESF |
| Kevin | Dionne | Maine-Fort Kent |
| Craig | Mitchell | WVU Tech |
| Steve | Tyrrell | SUNY ESF |
| Ryan | Foster | Southern Virginia University |
| Giovanni | Sinclair | Maine-Fort Kent |
| Christian | Bashios | NHTI |
| John | Dunn | WVU Tech |
2012 USCAA Men's Soccer Second Team All-Americans
| William | Banahene | SUNY Canton |
| Kristopher | Asmus | Ohio Mid-Western |
| Branden | Seeberger | Southern Virginia University |
| Chris | Hummel | PSU Hazleton |
| Joey | Killion | University of Dallas |
| Zac | McCulloch | Southern Virginia University |
| Jordan | Berry | Marygrove College |
| Tyler | Blake | PSU Beaver |
| Christopher | Brennan | Penn College |
| Trevor | Carignan | NHTI |
| Ben | Shade | Penn College |
| Kyle | Venditti | PSU Hazleton |
| Troy | Bacchus | Concordia College Alabama |
| Ryan | Graig | SUNY ESF |
| Kyle | Bardwell | SUNY ESF |
2012 USCAA Men's Soccer Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Abdoullie | Jallow | Marygrove College |
| Luis | Carlos | Concordia College Alabama |
| Kyle | Ehlers | Southern Maine CC |
| Ramon | Arce | Berkeley College NJ |
| Daniel | Caballero | Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Caio | De Costa | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Peter | Dore | Southern Maine CC |
| Zach | Hecox | Albany College of Pharmacy |
| Chad | Helberg | Rochester College |
| Christopher | Matthews | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Frank | Zeba | Maine-Machias |
| Olaff Alexis | Mina | Maine-Machias |
| Shenaldo | Parks | Concordia College Alabama |
| Phil | Bair | Penn College |
| Leighton | Richards | Concordia College Alabama |
| Luis | Herrera | Maine-Machias |
| Ryan | St. John | Rochester College |