| Stephanie | Runyon | St. Mary of the Woods |
| Alex | Leandri | PSU Wilkes Barre |
| Tatiyanah | Johnson | Dine College |
| Logan | Fry | St. Mary of the Woods |
| Kera | Nielson | Southern Virginia |
| Jordan | Weir | Daemen College |
| Kayla | Legassie | Maine-Presque Isle |
2012 USCAA Women's Cross Country Second Team All-Americans
| Karen | Hunsicker | Florida College |
| Hayley | Burnhauser | PSU Schuylkill |
| Clare | Myers | University of Dallas |
| Victoria | Faulkner | Southern Virginia University |
| Leah | Huber | Southern Virginia University |
| Sammie | Grove | Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Kristen | Campbell | SUNY ESF |