2011-12
- Baseball: Spalding University
- Basketball (Men's Division I): Oakwood University
- Basketball (Men's Division II): Andrews University
- Basketball (Women's): Concordia University-Selma
- Cross Country (Men's): SUNY ESF
- Cross Country (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Soccer (Men's): Lindenwood-Belleville
- Soccer (Women's): University of Maine-Fort Kent
- Softball: Spalding University
- Volleyball: Florida College
- Golf: Lindenwood-Belleville
2010-11
- Baseball: Briarcliffe College
- Basketball (Men's Division I): Southern Virginia University
- Basketball (Men's Division II): Andrews University
- Basketball (Women's): Ave Maria University
- Cross Country (Men's): Spalding University
- Cross Country (Women's): St. Mary-of-the-Woods
- Soccer (Men's): University of Maine at Fort Kent
- Soccer (Women's): University of Maine at Fort Kent
- Softball: Rochester College
- Volleyball: Florida College
- Golf: Rochester College
2009-10
- Baseball: Briarcliffe College
- Basketball (Men's Division I): Talladega College
- Basketball (Men's Division II): World Harverst Bible
- Basketball (Women's): Talladega College
- Cross Country (Men's): Dine College
- Cross Country (Women's): St. Mary-of-the-Woods
- Soccer (Men's): Concrodia College - Selma
- Soccer (Women's): Marygrove College
- Softball: RMU - Springfield
- Volleyball: Florida College
- Golf: Rochester College
- Baseball: St. Catharines College
- Basketball (Men's Division I): Talladega College
- Basketball (Men's Division II): Williamson
- Basketball (Women's): Spalding University
- Cross Country (Men's): Dine College
- Cross Country (Women's): Dine College
- Soccer (Men's): Briarcliffe College
- Soccer (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Softball: St. Catharines College
- Volleyball: Spalding University
- Golf: Pennsylvania College of Technology
- Baseball: Columbia Union College
- Basketball (Men's Division I): Oakwood University
- Basketball (Men's Division II): Williamson
- Basketball (Women's): Concordia-Selma
- Cross Country (Men's): Dine College
- Cross Country (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Soccer (Men's): Robert Morris Lake County
- Soccer (Women's): Robert Morris Springfield
- Softball: Saint Mary of the Woods
- Volleyball: Florida College
- Golf: The Apprentice School
- Baseball: Apprentice School
- Basketball (Men's Division I): Rhema Bible College
- Basketball (Men's Division II): University of Cincinnati Clermont
- Basketball (Women's): Concordia-Selma
- Cross Country (Men's): Dine College
- Cross Country (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Soccer (Men's): Rochester College
- Soccer (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Softball: Saint Mary of the Woods
- Volleyball: Florida College
- Golf (Men's): The Apprentice School
- Baseball: Briarcliffe College
- Basketball (Men's Division I): RHEMA Bible College
- Basketball (Men's Division II): Taylor University-Fort Wayne
- Basketball (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Cross Country (Men's): Dine College
- Cross Country (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Soccer (Men's): Bluefield College
- Soccer (Women's): Southern Virginia University
- Softball: Robert Morris-Springfield
- Volleyball: Florida College
- Golf (Men's): Apprentice School