2012 USCAA Women's Soccer All-Americans
| Katherine | Ferland | Maine-Fort Kent |
| Lora | Palmer | Southern Virginia University |
| Frances | Ripepi | Albany College of Pharmacy |
| Theresa | Biggs | Maine-Fort Kent |
| Sarah | Cope | Albany College of Pharmacy |
| Alexa | Amato | Daemen |
| Lainey | Herring | Maine-Presque Isle |
| Nicole | Landry | Paul Smith's College |
| Hannah | McElroy | Iowa Wesleyan College |
| Dannielle | Panuccio | Washington Adventist University |
| Marie-Michele | Lachance | Maine-Fort Kent |
| Tori | Capo | Carlow University |
| Ashley | Miller | SUNY-ESF |
| Jessica | Niemi | Marygrove College |
| Kimika | Forbes | Maine-Fort Kent |
2012 USCAA Women's Soccer Second Team All-Americans
| Cynthia | Gambino | St. Joseph's NY |
| Sydney | Kurz | Ohio Mid-Western |
| Emma | Legallais | Maine-Machias |
| Janelle | McIntyre | Carlow University |
| Valeria | Passalacqua | Penn College |
| Claire | Sexton | University of Dallas |
| Jade | Sorensen | Southern Virginia University |
| Samantha | Engel | Daemen |
| Makis | Gomez | Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Reily | Kennedy | Warren Wilson College |
| Alexis | Thayer | Albany College of Pharmacy |
| Nicolette | Blake | Carlow University |
| Ashlyn | Fratto | Carlow University |
| Alexandra | Weston | Albany College of Pharmacy |
| Reda | Vermilya | Penn College |
2012 USCAA Women's Soccer Honorable Mention All-Americans
| Michela | Desjardins | SMCC |
| Kylynn | Adams | Maine-Machias |
| Marin | Chambers | University of Dallas |
| Pamela | Chernyakhovsky | St. Joseph's NY |
| Nicole | Johnson | University of Dallas |
| Kaitlyn | Vigna | Marygrove College |
| Hannah | Fraser | Daemen |
| Tulia | LaCroix | NHTI |
| Emily | Morris | Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Nora | Nordike | Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Emily | Rogers | University of Dallas |
| Sydney | Yoscovits | Rochester College |
| Laura | Pratt | SUNY Canton |
| Nicole | Farinella | St. Joseph's NY |
| Carissa | Pelletier | NHTI |