Non-Championship Sport National All-Academic Team
December 9, 2019
| Nominee | School | Year |
| Jessica Biller | SUNY Delhi | Sr. |
| Sarah Krzyston | SUNY Delhi | Jr. |
| Susan Hoskins | SUNY Delhi | Sr. |
| Giuseppe Polino | Williamson College fo the Trades | Jr. |
| Anthony Marascio | Williamson College fo the Trades | Jr. |
| Hunter Thornton | Williamson College of the Trades | Sr. |
| Jordan Hooks | Judson College | Sr. |
| Samantha Pearce | Judson College | So. |
| Anna Mag Reynolds | Judson College | Jr. |
| Lexy Small | Judson College | Sr. |
| Tessa Thompson | Judson College | Jr. |
| Casey Rogers | Judson College | Sr. |
| Kirsten Britnell | Judson College | Sr. |
| Hope Langkow | Judson College | Sr. |
| Else Bielarski | Paul Smith's College | So. |
| Cody Evanchick | Paul Smith's College | Sr. |
| Austin Delosh | Paul Smith's College | Jr. |
| Justin Engler | Paul Smith's College | Jr. |
| Caitlin Fortin | Paul Smith's College | Sr. |
| Lauren Mullen | Paul Smith's College | Jr. |
| Dana Tripp | Paul Smith's College | Jr. |
| Connor Edmonds | Paul Smith's College | Jr. |
| Jaden Sanborn | Paul Smith's College | So. |
| Rex Schweighofer | Paul Smith's College | Sr. |
| Daniel Power | Paul Smith's College | Jr. |
| Jared Jones | Paul Smith's College | Sr. |
| Christopher Squillante | Paul Smith's College | |
| Bella Cimeno | Warren Wilson College | So |
| Morgan Landis | Warren Wilson College | Sr. |
| Lucy Packer | Warren Wilson College | Jr. |
| Griffin Harvey | Warren Wilson College | So. |
| Sierra Bell | Warren Wilson College | Jr. |